Europe needs to get real on defence; Britain needs to get real on Europe
13 February 2025
Post
24 March 2011
2 minute(s) read
Recent Posts
Posted by Alastair Campbell
589. The Trump-Xi-Putin Summit and Can the UK Ever Trust America Again?
With Trump, Xi and Putin set to meet this week, what is it really like sitting across the negotiating table from world leaders, and what makes dealing with China so different? With the Jensen Huang an... Continue17 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
215. Is Burnham Doing Enough to Learn From Starmer’s Mistakes? | Mariana Mazzucato
Why has Britain under-invested for decades, and can “mission-led” government fix it? Is the UK government being "infantilised" by consultants? Why is the US outgrowing Europe, and what should Andy... Continue16 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
What Living Under ISIS Taught Me About Extremism
Twenty-five years after 9/11, does terrorism still pose an existential threat to humanity? How do ordinary people become extremists — and why is it a mistake to generalise about the “type” of pe... Continue13 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
588. Is Britain Prepared for Cyber Warfare and The ‘Plot’ to Undermine the UN
As supermarket fridges are hacked and bomb threats are called in, how is AI accelerating the rate of cyberattacks, and can Britain’s defences keep up? Who is in the running to become the next UN Sec... Continue12 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Posted by Alastair Campbell
587. Will a Weakened Trump Make the World More Dangerous?
Following the disastrous midterm results for the Republicans, where will Trump turn his attention for the last two years of his presidency, and what will the MAGA movement look like without him? With ... Continue11 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
214. What Can The UK Learn From How South Africa Ended Apartheid? (Paul van Zyl)
How can politicians rebuild trust after decades of division? How do you get political enemies to sit down at the same table? What are some of Nelson Mandela's best - and funniest - moments? Alastair ... Continue9 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Many say irony died with Henry Kissinger won the Nobel Peace Prize but I think its corpse got a good kicking again yesterday when Osborne started talking about a society being judged by the compassion of its people.
And then he serves up the same old dreary, supply side dogma – make things as cheap and easy for business as possible and everything will turn out fine. As for the people that work for them (or more to the point, don’t, given the current economic situation), well your welfare, aspirations and wellbeing aren’t really worth a mention since you are just fodder to feed the machine. Oh hang on have a net minus 2p saving on petrol, that’ll keep you quiet.
Did anyone else notice that someone appears to have cut a couple of inches of Gideon;s trousers. Cuts cuts cuts. Either that or he is wearing an old pair from whem he was growing up with Dave in Bullingdonland. At least his colleagues looked embarrassed when he said we were all in it together
Saw you striding purposefully up Whitehall yesterday. Hope you were on way to help Labour start landing blows on these people. Ed did ok yesterday, but they are still getting away with murder. At least Clegg looked out of it. One down …
Osborne doesn’t need a spin doctor … he has Nick Robinson
The economic policy of the Tory-led government has clearly failed.
Inflation is at 4.4%. Unemployment 2.5m. GDP contracted 0.6%.
Growth will be only 1.7% this year. Public sector borrowing will be £44.5bn higher across the parliament. Unemployment will be higher every year from now.
This is all because of premature retrenchment. Britain is facing years of sluggish growth.
Private sector will not be able to create as many jobs as expected. Inflation will be high. Debt will reach £1.36tr. Benefits costs will go up. Deficit will remain higher for longer.
Only over 3% growth will save Mr Osborne. But where will that come from?
Huge redistribution of wealth from the poor and middle classes to super-rich is taking place. At the same time the government is remodelling Britain against the wishes of the majority.
There is no economic need for £111bn of cuts and tax rises. As Jonathan Portes has said, the real hit to credibility comes from sticking to unsustainable policies.
Britain´s underlying growth rate has remained unchanged at about 2% for a century or more. Larry Elliott wrote in the Guardian that it is hard to imagine Osborne´s plan working.
A combination of public sector job cuts, pay freezes, inflation and tax increases mean low consumer confidence.
According to recent IPPR paper 1.5% growth or below is the point at which the Treasury should draw back from deficit reduction.
In the midst of oil price shock, eurozone debt and crisis in Japan, austerity is not the right tonic for the UK economy. It will only make a bad situation even harder.
For growth, we need smart government and modern industrial policy.
George Osborne is taking unnecessary risk with his neo-Thatcherite approach. He is cutting too far and too fast. A plan B is needed.
The cuts will come with huge economic and social cost.
But there will, of course, always be David Cameron´s Big Society to take care of those hit hardest..?
Ps. One more thing. George Osborne claimed on Tuesday that Labour placed all bets on the financial sector. This is not true. The financial sector brings in only 11.2% of the UK´s total tax take. Banking sector takes up 10% of GDP, manufacturing 14%.
‘Sat around moaning about things..’ Sounds familiar.
I see that winter fuel allowance for pensioners is being cut, although it was not announced in the Budget.
What happened to “Watch my lips” Dave’s promises before the election, and his denouncement of Labour’s “lies” that the allowance was not safe in Tory hands.
No wonder it wasn’t spoken about in Parliament. One for PMQ’s, maybe.
Thanks to Rosie for drawing attention to the cut in Winter Fuel Payments. Having checked it out, I see that my 98 year old father will lose a massive £100 from his Winter Fuel Payment.
So far they’ve succeeded in keeping this quiet but it should be widely publicised and it’s something to write/email your Tory or LibDem MP about.
Strange how Sir Martin Sorrell said nothing more than WPP would “look” at moving back to the UK subject to (1) board of director and (2) shareholder approval and (3) enactment of legislation. Pretty much nothing binding had been said at all. You would not think so from the attention it has received around the media.
Stranger still then that some savvy tweeters had all come to the conclusion that WPP had already signed a lease in Canary Wharf and used similar words to tweet as much all unconfined by what Sir Martin had actually said. Then George Osborne flies in to the Today Programme chirping the same mangled WPP song. Sadly the BBC helpfully joined in this dawn chorus with some undeservedly harmonic reporting based on a slightly over- optimistic assessment of the facts.
It may well be that WPP will move its HQ back to the UK. Recent Corporation Tax changes will mean that it will only pay UK tax on about 10% of its worldwide earnings and will benefit more than most UK companies from them. If WPP does return that is also good for the UK as we need them. Lower tax rates can give greater tax yields, but there are unlikely to be many more WPP birds out there in the subsidised Irish tax bush. At best the CT and other Budget changes will be a slow-burn incentive to inward investment in the UK and they are unlikely to stimulate any much-needed real growth spurt.
What really sticks in the craw, though, is the discordant pro-Government post-Budget propaganda wrung from a heavily qualified and apparently premature announcement of WPP’s return to the UK nest. It may have enabled the Chancellor to big-up the effect of his Budget on as yet unknown other business organisations which may include some that had already signed up to the Tory manifesto before the Election. It has, however, obviously taken its toll on George Osborne’s larynx and has left him struggling to hit any really convincing Budget high notes.
*(Not) Tagged: “tweeters” “tweeting” “dawn chorus” “budget” “for the birds”*
What a complete load of tosh! You say “the government is remodelling Britain against the wishes of the majority” and yet say nothing about the social engineering undertaken by Labour. 3 million immigrants without schools, hospitals, education facilities plus all of the staff. Labour has managed to put the appropriate ‘controls’ into place to completely ruin the economy; Brown has put so many poisoned pills there it will take years to work them out of the system.
The public sector hasn’t seen the pain of cuts yet, they have been trimming around the edges and somehow have managed to not cut all the quangos as promised.
I was greatly pleased that there was nothing for the chatterati on Budget Day + 1. This was indeed a “nothing” Budget and excellent for that. After Brown’s pointless micromanagement it’s great to have a government trying to keep out of people’s daily lives.
As usual Chris I’m not sure whether, behind the cheap Gordon Brown insult, a valid point is being made or not. Are you saying that the best kind of Budget is no Budget? Are you also saying that this government is keeping out of people’s daily lives by, for example, making a drastic cut in the winter fuel allowance which it promised, pre-election, not to touch? And when you talk about the chatterati do you include people like yourself who use this blog? No doubt you’ll elaborate and back up your argument with lots of facts. Otherwise people like me might be wondering what exactly you are saying.