Mail not welcome in Ireland, but peace is

  • Post

  • 7 February 2011

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 17

Busy busy yesterday, no time to blog, but I hope you caught up on the Mail's latest piece of villainy. Journalism is a competitive trade, but to pass yourself off as a competitor, when said competitor has just gone into receivership, and forty plus journalists are staring at the dole, is a blow lower than most. I do wonder if Dacre ever looks in a mirror, and then looks around his newsrooms and is happy at what he sees. What the Mail on Sunday did was to put a four page wrap, complete with Sunday Tribune masthead, around what in fact was the Mail on Sunday. They called it marketing, and said they were trying to make sure Irish readers still had a choice of newspaper. It was a con pure and simple. Once a bit of a hoo-ha erupted, it was a con which led to some newsagents removing it from their shelves. Would that everyone took a similar stance to this pernicious rag. I am in Belfast today, speaking to students at Queen's University, later meeting people at the Assembly, and doing far too many interviews for my own good. I went out for a run last night and you don't have to be here long to see that despite the challenges, this is a better place as a result of the Peace Process which took up so much of Tony Blair's time and energy. It was always enjoyable, if always challenging, to come here - for a start, the NI story tended to detrivialise our media, the local media were desperate for us to succeed, and there were some very big characters involved in the politics here. The eventual coming together of Ian Paisley and Martin McGuinness as the so-called Chuckle brothers remains one of the most surreal, but satisfying moments of the Blair Years.

17 responses to “Mail not welcome in Ireland, but peace is”

  1. Great to read a quote on the RTE News website by Noirin Hegarty, Editor of the Sunday Tribune – “The Mail On Sunday has shown in this act that it will leave no stone unturned in the race to the bottom.” Sums the Mail up entirely I think!

  2. Fair play to you for your forthright words on Newstalk radio yesterday morning, Alastair. It was good to hear yourself and Roy Greenslade tell it like is from a UK media perspective. Though even you two sounded shocked by this stunt. Like many people in Ireland I was puzzled when I saw the Sunday Tribune masthead on a newsagent’s shelf – and in disbelief when I realised that this was an act of identity theft by the ‘Irish’ Mail. The Sunday Tribune has been the closest thing we Irish have had to The Observer – a quality Sunday that is not overwhelmingly rightwing. Its loss is just awful news for Irish journalism. Which makes the Mail’s stunt an act of pure cultural imperialism. Surely it must also be illegal? If something like this were to happen in the UK, what would the legal situation be?

  3. As you are in NI with its own somewhat complicated voting system I rather fancy going off topic with a discussion of AV.

    EdM has, in my view, done the right thing by announcing today he’ll not appear with Clegg on a Yes platform.

    On the other hand, like many other Socialists, I find myself stuck firmly as a “Don’t Know” on the issue.

    At university we had elimination elections for union officers and we are used to it internally within the Labour party.

    AV is very sensible – in the tweeds and brogues sense – because we end up with a successful candidate that at least half of the voters will have some truck with.

    On the other hand, look at Australia where AV basically allows several notionally competing Tory parties not be in competition at all.

    And on yet a third hand my late father found himself perfunctorily booted off the old West Midlands County council in the 1980’s when the Conservative agent cocked up his candidate’s nomination papers. All the Tories voted Liberal!

    That said, the winning Liberal candidate David Luscombe was a very VERY good man and his decline through Multiple Sclerosis was a terrible loss to his party and to the citizens of Birmingham. I’d have had no problem giving him a second preference under AV.

    Yes, EdM is absolutely correct to distance himself from Nick Clegg on this issue. It is much too important.

  4. “Mail not welcome in most of England either”, you can safely say. However, It has become the Bible of middle England.
    All of the “what the papers say” sections of TV progs slavishly give vent to the Mail “tosh” day after day. Many of the invited commentators on these shows are themselves journalists and writers who would love to take the Dacre shilling.
    As for the new “Chuckle Brothers” of unlikely soulmates, I nominate “Two Jags” and Ian Hislop. You could not make it up!

  5. Thank you for coming to QUB. I was in the university. Mr Campbell, if I may ask a question, a few times during your lecture you said ‘Never give up’, both in politics and as a rule in life. May I ask, is there such a thing as futility?

  6. I’m still in the “Don’t Know” camp regarding AV. Hoping that the whole issue may in due course become easier to make a decision on.

  7. I’m pleased you agree with me about the Mail, thanks 🙂
    and regarding the football we all have different views!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

589. The Trump-Xi-Putin Summit and Can the UK Ever Trust America Again?

With Trump, Xi and Putin set to meet this week, what is it really like sitting across the negotiating table from world leaders, and what makes dealing with China so different? With the Jensen Huang an... Continue

17 November 2026

215. Is Burnham Doing Enough to Learn From Starmer’s Mistakes? | Mariana Mazzucato

Why has Britain under-invested for decades, and can “mission-led” government fix it? Is the UK government being "infantilised" by consultants? Why is the US outgrowing Europe, and what should Andy... Continue

16 November 2026

What Living Under ISIS Taught Me About Extremism

Twenty-five years after 9/11, does terrorism still pose an existential threat to humanity? How do ordinary people become extremists — and why is it a mistake to generalise about the “type” of pe... Continue

13 November 2026

588. Is Britain Prepared for Cyber Warfare and The ‘Plot’ to Undermine the UN

As supermarket fridges are hacked and bomb threats are called in, how is AI accelerating the rate of cyberattacks, and can Britain’s defences keep up? Who is in the running to become the next UN Sec... Continue

12 November 2026

587. Will a Weakened Trump Make the World More Dangerous?

Following the disastrous midterm results for the Republicans, where will Trump turn his attention for the last two years of his presidency, and what will the MAGA movement look like without him? With ... Continue

11 November 2026

214. What Can The UK Learn From How South Africa Ended Apartheid? (Paul van Zyl)

How can politicians rebuild trust after decades of division? How do you get political enemies to sit down at the same table? What are some of Nelson Mandela's best - and funniest - moments? Alastair ... Continue

9 November 2026