Europe needs to get real on defence; Britain needs to get real on Europe
13 February 2025
Post
2 April 2010
3 minute(s) read
Recent Posts
Join Alastair Campbell and Mishal Husain live at Cadogan Hall
Persevilience: The word the world needs now is the title of Alastair Campbell’s new book. It is also the starting point for a conversation with... Continue14 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
206. How Putin’s War Changed Finland Forever (Sanna Marin)
Following Putin's war in Ukraine, how politically challenging was it committing Finland to join NATO? What was it like becoming the world's youngest sitting prime minister at 34? Why did a scandal ove... Continue14 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
“Our Generation Was Lied To”: Two Gen Z MPs on Fixing Politics
To hear the full series “The Gen Z Story”, sign up at the restispolitics.com – use your student email for a discount How do you get older colleagues to take you seriously when you become an MP ... Continue11 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
570. Why Trump Acts Like a Russian Asset and Miliband’s West Bank Sanctions
After Trump’s latest betrayal of Ukraine, why does he act like a Russian asset? Has John Healy already missed his moment to be a radical Chancellor, and does Ed Miliband’s move to impose economic ... Continue10 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
569. Farage’s Foreign Funding Scandal and Germany’s Far-Right Breakthrough
As the Alternative for Germany party secured its best ever election result in Saxony-Anhalt, is the country about to get its first far-right state premier since the Nazi Party, and will Chancellor Fri... Continue9 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
9 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
205. Anthony Scaramucci: Why America Keeps Making the Same Mistakes
Why does Anthony Scaramucci think Osama bin Laden is “winning”, and what has the War on Terror really cost America? From letting China into the WTO to bailing out the banks in 2008, how did Americ... Continue7 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Becoming Burnham: The Manchester Arena Call, Westminster Plotting, and Keir vs Andy
To hear the full episode, and the whole series, sign up at therestispolitics.com How did Andy Burnham learn about the Manchester Arena bombing? Would he still have tried to become PM had Keir Starmer... Continue3 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
I always think you have to worry when the person who tells you something is broken and you can’t really see it, is the same person who offers to fix it. Wheither that by dodgy Dave the cowboy builder or Dave the politician.
Any experienced politics-watcher would acknowledge that the tide has moved firmly back in David Cameron’s favour this week. And the polls continue to be just terrible for Labour. Only 29% in today’s Guardian. From his excellent National Insurance tax cut to the jobs tax attack, to Labour’s panic retreat on the Death Tax, this has been the week that the Tories won the election. Alan Johnson’s woeful performance on BBC Question Time last night was symptomatic of a Labour party facing the firing squad.
Its time for change.
I’m always amused when the Tories bang on about ‘broken Britain’. To quote the late, great Bill Hicks “Where is this sh*t happening?” The answer of course is that it’s not. Yes there are deprived communities, yes this country faces a multiple of challenges but to suggest it’s broken is just wrong.
The ‘Broken Britain’ tag the Tories are trying to hang on this country won’t ring true with the electorate because it simply *isn’t* true.
Ironically, due to recent scandals such as MPs’ expenses etc I believe the public actually feel *more* empowered than at any time in the past few decades. They are looking closely at their elected representatives and what they say and no longer taking anything at face value.
Great for Labour. Not so good for the Tories. Ou est le soleil pour le Conservatives?
The broken society is a myth for sure…however there are still problems and much still to be done.
I was reminded yesterday of how people mis-judge our youth and do them a real injustice. At the checkout of my local Tesco’s a young lad (12-13ish)in front of me had what looked like a few days essentials (bread milk etc) when the girl finished adding it all up the young lad was short by 43p
embarassed he went bright red and looked for something he could put back.
I offered 50p to the girl and said “its ok I don’t mind”.
The lad was grateful and insisted he will get the money from his mum who was in the carpark.
I said “ok dont worry its not a problem”….never expecting to see my money ever again.
As I walked to my car the young lad ran up to me with 50p and thanked me while he pressed the money into my hand.
I was surprised but as he walked away I noticed him walking towards an large lady in a car who must have been his mum. The car had a disabled sign on the front and on the back window.
Now Cameron’s Britain would tell the story a very different way…..infact I doubt anyone would recognise it.
Dear A C
This is brilliant. thank you for making me aware of the 25th hr I have shard it with my Facebook Friends and encourage others to do so.
Jesus is thought to have died on the Cross at 3pm on Good (God’s ) Friday.
Bets wishes for Easter. Thank you for the blog -is it one year or two years now?
gary
As usual Ally, where Manchester leads the rest of the country follows, ie Manchester’s 2002 Commonwealth games was a success due to the army of volunteers, now the cockneys imitate us.
Btw as you’re a film buff, The 25th Hour is also a cracking film, directed by Spike Lee starring Edward Norton.
Some people I’ve canvassed have said they feel insulted by the broken Britain tag. Not quite as insulted perhaps as those who live in a ward described by their one Lib Dem councillor (bless him) as “a slum”.
Properly handled in the short campaign, this Tory smear could backfire on them.
And don’t get me started on Cameron talking up the importance of the community and voluntary sector whilst all across the land his Tory councillors are busy imposing stealth cuts on the sector’s budgets so they can shave tuppence a year off the council tax bills…
The Conservatives claiming that britain is a broken society denies very unfairly the efforts of thousands of long standing service clubs. I speak of Rotary, Lions, Round Table (of which there are about 1000 clubs EACH in the UK) plus offshoots such as Rotaract. All have as members folk who want to put something back into society. All have strong community service activities.
I was involved with one of these organisations for about 10 years before mental health issues and elderly parental care duties dominated my life.
The organisation in question has an acid test “The four way test” which members are expected to apply in the things they think, say or do:
Is it the truth?
Is it fair to all concerned?
Will it build goodwill and better friendships?
Will it be beneficial to all concerned?
It is a VERY tough test by which to conduct one’s affairs as it is very easy on the one hand to accuse others of failing to comply with one part of the test but, on the other hand, one’s own accusation probably falls foul of a different part of the test.
For example calling somebody a liar is not exactly working to build goodwill and better friendships nor is it often fair.
The problem as I see it with politicians becoming involved with volunteering as a matter of POLICY is that in a democratic society the tools and practice (practise?)of politics are difficult to reconcile with the four way test.
All very commendable stuff but what has it got to do with the ‘broken Britain’ tag ? one that is even more relevant now with the horrendous levels of debt this government has saddled us with.
You’d had to be blind to believe that 13 years of Labour’s failed policies hasn’t adversely affected this country.
Mt Gittins,
If I may, how is granting a £200,000 inheritance tax break to the 3000 richest households in the land going to improve matters in the Britain you are describing as “broken”?
On the subject of “Broken Britain”, I think that if you were to ask the people you know, “what is broken about Britain?” they would talk about banks, parliamentary expenses, non-dom peers etc. I don’t think they would say that looking at our society it is clear that the problems it faces are caused by the residents of impoverished areas of the UK.
If there is some kind of moral breakdown in the UK then it is at the top, in finance and in politics.
I think this is where the Conservative party has been so wrong. For David Cameron to enter impoverished housing estates with a camera crew, on his crusade against “Broken Britain” it does seem really rather hypocritical. To find a moral breakdown in British society David Cameron needs to look rather closer to home.
@ Robert J: good posts, especially about the four rules.
I think more people are waking up to the fact that Dave isn’t sincere, and is just coming out with whatever soundbite he thinks is going to push the right buttons. The actions of his own party undermine what he says – the example about volunteer groups’ grants being cut by Tory councils says it all.
First impressions of the new poster aren’t as high as they could be. However, after a few inspections it does begin to plant a few seeds. It reminds me of the 1980’s as it’s intended. but it also makes me think back to the recession of that decade. It reminds me how the tory government walked away from taking actiion to protect jobs and people: it reminds me how the tory government blamed ‘market forces’ for everything, and how they were powerless to act (now we see that you can, and must act); and it reminds me of the two cities of Thatcherism, one was built from greed, and the other was built from cardboard. Why does Labour not use the cardboard city to back up the 1980’s narrative. The Gene Hunt poater is not enough, not merely because people like this character in the show. It’s the world he inhabited that needs to be painted, to leave the electorate in no doubt, as to what a tory government does in an emergency, and how they close ranks in their country manors.How about a cyberspace world of the 1980’s, where people can see what it was like for themselves. I don’t know what the budget is like, but it may be worth investigating. Another idea is to use MTV style videos, which connect quicker with people.