Thanks to Charlie Falconer and Dominic Grieve – yes, I know he is a Tory

  • Post

  • 21 October 2009

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 6

This could be a first - a blog containing thanks to a Tory. Not just any old Tory, but the shadow justice secretary Dominic Grieve. Mr Grieve debated the future of human rights with former Lord Chancellor Charlie Falconer in front of a room full of human rights lawyers at Doughty Street chambers in London last night. The event was the idea of what the papers might call my common-law-brother-in-law, Gavin Millar QC, in support of Leukaemia Research's efforts to raise 50k in memory of Henry Hodge as part of our 50th anniversary celebrations next year, when we want 50 such 50k donations, and 'in memory of Henry Hodge'  to be one of the first. We are still counting, and still chasing a few cheques, but the proceeds from last night are well into five figures already, so many thanks to Dominic, Charlie, Gavin, to Polly Toynbee who chaired it, and to all those who paid to hear the debate. There - I've said it. Thanks to Dominic. That is me thanking a Tory. Enjoy the moment. It was great to see Charlie back in action. I always enjoyed working with him, and he was a good brain to have around when difficult questions were being addressed. Last night, with his usual wit and his usual shirt-hanging-out-of-trousers look, he tried to pick up inconsistencies between Mr Grieve's speech to his party conference -  shall we say sceptical on human rights - and the pro human rights speech he made last night to a room full of human rights lawyers. Perhaps the funniest moment of the evening came when Charlie said that if the Toies got into power, Dominic was 'our best hope for human rights ... because you should see the rest.' But as I am being in kindly and grateful mood, I will merely take at face value Mr Grieve's commitment that a Tory government would operate within the ECHR, his expressions of support for the Human Rights Act, albeit with some criticisms too, and his belief that any changes would be to extend rather than curtail rights. So thanks again to all of them. If you'd have said to me in the morning that I would enjoy an evening listening to lawyers arguing about human rights, I would have been a bit dubious, what with Champions League being on the telly last night. But I did. So did Henry's widow Margaret. So will the Leikaemia Research bank manager. And no, not so that he can use it to jack up his bonus.

6 responses to “Thanks to Charlie Falconer and Dominic Grieve – yes, I know he is a Tory”

  1. A rare bit of heartening news. Uplifting too.
    And it gets better as you can now watch Chelsea live on ITV tonight.

  2. Tories in charge of human rights? Come off it. Next they’ll be putting your friend Paul Dacre in charge of the Press Complaints Commission code! Oh, they did …

  3. The HRA is a superb piece of legislation, one of the best things the Labour government has done. I sometimes think that you emphasised the wrong reasons for doing it, but the end product is what matters and I for one celebrate its presence on the Statute Book. Most of the criticisms of it are based on myth.

  4. ‘The HRA is a superb piece of legislation’

    That has to be the funniest statement I’ve ever read on here. The idea in principle is great, the legislation itself and the way it has been applied has been a disaster.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

476. Polanski’s Problem, Westminster’s Russia Blind Spot, and Justice Without Juries? (Question Time)

Are the Greens selling an economic vision they can’t explain? Should Britain ditch juries in some trials? And, how far has Russian influence seeped into UK politics? Join Rory and Alastair... Continue

4 December 2025

475. The Budget Backlash – and Trump’s Plan to Profit from Peace in Ukraine

Is the media too negative about Reeves and Starmer, or are they simply out of ideas? What has the relentless Budget turmoil and fallout done to already low levels of trust in the Government? ... Continue

3 December 2025

164. Zack Polanski: Do The Greens Have What It Takes?

Why has Green party membership exploded since Zack Polanski became leader in September? What radical economic reforms is he fighting for? Why have the Greens stopped talking about the environ... Continue

1 December 2025

474. What Does the Budget Mean for You?

Was this 'the most leaked Budget' of all time? Has Rachel Reeves managed to balance the demands of the public, the markets, industry, and her party? Can Reeves turn around the Government’s ... Continue

26 November 2025

Alastair Campbell’s diary: We expect politicians to lie – and that’s the problem

We have become too accustomed to figures like Donald Trump, who see misinformation as a weapon rather than a issue... Continue

26 November 2025

Article

Posted by

473. Europe vs. Trump: Competing Visions for a Ukraine Peace Deal (Question Time)

What happens to global leadership when the US ghosts the G20 and COP, and can middle powers really keep the world moving? Is Britain ignoring a major foreign-interference scandal? And, how cl... Continue

26 November 2025

163. Prison Reform, Masculinity, and Restorative Justice (James Graham and Jacob Dunne)

Jacob Dunne killed someone as a teenager, how did he seek forgiveness from his victim’s parents? What is restorative justice? How did Jacob’s experience of the criminal justice system com... Continue

24 November 2025

472. Is Trump’s Peace ‘Plan’ Forced Surrender for Ukraine?

Who is really behind the White House 'peace plan' for Ukraine: Trump or Putin? Why isn't Europe taking the threat from Russia more seriously, and doing more to protect Ukraine? How does all o... Continue

23 November 2025