Europe needs to get real on defence; Britain needs to get real on Europe
13 February 2025
Post
21 March 2009
5 minute(s) read
Recent Posts
215. Is Burnham Doing Enough to Learn From Starmer’s Mistakes? | Mariana Mazzucato
Why has Britain under-invested for decades, and can “mission-led” government fix it? Is the UK government being "infantilised" by consultants? Why is the US outgrowing Europe, and what should Andy... Continue16 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
What Living Under ISIS Taught Me About Extremism
Twenty-five years after 9/11, does terrorism still pose an existential threat to humanity? How do ordinary people become extremists — and why is it a mistake to generalise about the “type” of pe... Continue13 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
588. Is Britain Prepared for Cyber Warfare and The ‘Plot’ to Undermine the UN
As supermarket fridges are hacked and bomb threats are called in, how is AI accelerating the rate of cyberattacks, and can Britain’s defences keep up? Who is in the running to become the next UN Sec... Continue12 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Posted by Alastair Campbell
587. Will a Weakened Trump Make the World More Dangerous?
Following the disastrous midterm results for the Republicans, where will Trump turn his attention for the last two years of his presidency, and what will the MAGA movement look like without him? With ... Continue11 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
214. What Can The UK Learn From How South Africa Ended Apartheid? (Paul van Zyl)
How can politicians rebuild trust after decades of division? How do you get political enemies to sit down at the same table? What are some of Nelson Mandela's best - and funniest - moments? Alastair ... Continue9 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
586. Trump’s Midterms Disaster: What Happens Next?
Why did Trump concede defeat so quickly and pledge to work with Democrats, and what does this mean for the final two years of his presidency, including his influence on the world stage? Was this a cos... Continue4 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Alastair Campbell’s diary: My biblical battles with Zia Yusuf and Jacob Rees-Mogg
The faithful have long since abandoned the promised land of Brexit – but the false prophets won’t admit it... Continue4 November 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
It sounds as thought you secretly admire Dave. With the centre ground of politics being quite crowded i predict if Cons win next election they will bring “others” on board and Dave could do a lot worse than include yourself in his team
I have to admit to being head over heels in love with Daniel Finkelstein. He’s thoughtful, intelligent and extremely likeable.
The Tories are in opposition. It is the job of the Her Majesty’s loyal opposition to hold the Government to account. That job is far more important than driving their own agenda and flogging their policy for an election that has not yet been called. It is absolutely right that Labour’s policies are more scrutinised by the press – they are in power.
Do you think the saying: ‘there’s no such thing as bad publicity’ has merit?
I too love the Fink Tank. So much of what passes for punditry is just opinion about other people’s opinions. Yet there is so much statistical information to be had and more use should be made of it. As for Cameron, I agree on that too. He is obviously hoping that the desire for change is enough.
Can’t you edit the New Statesman every week? I’ve not read it for a while, and this week I really enjoyed it. I’m not a football fan but the talk with Alex Ferguson was interesting. I enjoyed the education spread and I liked reading a more sensible article for once on civil liberties. I missed the Week In Westminster but I will definitely watch you reviewing In The Loop.
@AC “Cameron is hugely helped by the bias in the media which takes nothing Labour says at face value……”
Alastair. Only you, the spinmeister’s spinmeister, could have the hutzpah to come out with this!
They tone did change when Cameron became leader but he’s used the excuse of the recession to slowly bring it back to a mory orthodox Thatcherite agenda.
He wants to take us out of the Social Chapter (still as yet the thickos at Labour HQ haven’t seized on this…no surprise there), he has now said that education will be cut, only the NHS and defence will be safe. Here on defence, Liam Fox has stated he will look at more “off the shelf” purchases instead of supporting UK industry, yet again not taken up by the dummies at HQ.
BTW Ally, you signed book, “All in the Mind” went for a fair few quid at a Manchester Labour fund raiser last night which I attended.
Say that again, please! What? The Tories are scared?
I submitted my article to The New Statesman in the hope of starting a conversation on substance. In part, it was meant for Labour supporters to appreciate what in my view is a strong policy record, and work hard to take the Party into a fourth term, deservedly so! But it was also meant for our colleagues across the political aisle, inviting them to assess the strength of their platform and then engage in a debate with us on substantive policy issues.
After completing the article, I prepared myself (with facts and policy papers to my side) to respond to any inquiries about my argument, my choice for certain policy instruments, the basis of my predictions and so on. I was also ready to defend my comparison with U.S. policies and how I thought they were relevant to the British case.
But much to my chagrin, until now the other side has only advanced anti-intellectual sophistry and linguistic filth. Questioning my legitimacy to even open my mouth on these matters, they dismissed me as a “random Master’s student,” “from a different planet,” and a “urinal” among others. Fair enough, this is a free country and everyone is entitled to their opinions. I asked them to move on and join me, instead, in a substantive discussion about the real issues that the people of this country care about so deeply. (True, a “urinal” can be distracting, but they should cover their eyes and noses, and still be able to think, right?) But at this point my call met with their silence.
All they can do apparently is engage in an expletive orgy and a lot of noise that masks their intellectual silence. Lapsing into grotesque personae, they dismiss a statement about supply and demand by calling you names, and then question factual accounts not on the basis of other facts but one the basis of your identity.
However, the Tories’ vulgar response to this issue of the New Statesman has had at least one virtue: it shows a scared lot that communicates exclusively out of anger and frustration, with no policy record to rely upon. It also demonstrates that the Tory disaster begins at home. So far, their supporters have managed to distinguish themselves through their difficulty uttering coherent opinions on the most basic issues of the day.
The forceful set of articles in the magazine has rendered the Tories scrambling to attack with cheap and irrelevant shots. Above all, we can now see that when Labour sympathizers discuss matters seriously, the Tories look as if they’re trying to take a sip out of a fire hydrant.
I trust that the undecided voters out there will remark this distinction, and make their electoral judgment accordingly.
Since we seem to be entering an unprecidented world economic situation, could it be possible that the Conservatives actually don’t really have the stomach for the fight – would they perhaps sooner lose the next General Election, enjoy criticising the government while they flounder in uncharted waters, and then force a vote of no confidence at some point when they think they can see some hope of an upturn?
I know politicians must be extremely ambitious and driven to succeed, but there must be a point when it seems prudent to bide your time ….
It’s been enlightening to watch Dave on the sidelines during the unfolding of the economic situation. Maybe he thinks pursing his lips, shaking his head and saying (I paraphrase, but not by much)”Ooooh, I wouldn’t have done *that*,” bodes well as a vote winner? Easy cheap vibes, but nothing positive to offer. Computer says no.
PS. Labour ahead in the polls by 8% on the NHS.
Patients say yes.
Jibes! Not vibes. Got this wrong in previous post.