Europe needs to get real on defence; Britain needs to get real on Europe
13 February 2025
Post
18 September 2018
3 minute(s) read
Recent Posts
205. Anthony Scaramucci: Why America Keeps Making the Same Mistakes
Why does Anthony Scaramucci think Osama bin Laden is “winning”, and what has the War on Terror really cost America? From letting China into the WTO to bailing out the banks in 2008, how did Americ... Continue7 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Becoming Burnham: The Manchester Arena Call, Westminster Plotting, and Keir vs Andy
To hear the full episode, and the whole series, sign up at therestispolitics.com How did Andy Burnham learn about the Manchester Arena bombing? Would he still have tried to become PM had Keir Starmer... Continue3 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
568. MAGA’s Plan to Make Britain Look Broken and Iceland’s ‘Brexit’ Moment
Did Iceland's rejection of EU membership talks repeat the same mistakes as Britain's Remain campaign, and does it hand a dangerous propaganda win to Farage, Putin, and the wider anti-European right? A... Continue3 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
567. Who Really Benefits from AI and Will Data Centres Decide the Midterms?
Why is the backlash against data centres becoming one of the most combustible issues in US politics? What does an AI system's attempt to cheat, cover its tracks, and break into another company’s web... Continue2 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
2 September 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
204. Will a Wealth Tax Actually Fix Britain? (Dan Neidle)
Why does tax expert Dan Neidle take Gabriel Zucman seriously as a thinker on inequality, but dismiss Gary Stevenson's warnings as populism? What did he uncover in Peter Mandelson's emails, and how did... Continue31 August 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Becoming Burnham: People Pleasing, The Shadow Years and Losing to Jeremy Corbyn
Who are the political figures that shaped Andy Burnham? How far will the new PM go to be liked? And what impact did losing to Jeremy Corbyn's popularity 'tsunami' have on his career - and confidence? ... Continue27 August 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
566. Carney vs. Trump and Alastair’s Advice for Burnham’s First PMQs
Why is Mark Carney choosing economic pain over a deal on tariffs with Trump? As Palestinians prepare to vote for the first time in 20 years, why has Mahmoud Abbas decided that now is finally the momen... Continue27 August 2026
Posted by Alastair Campbell
Hello Alastair, I used to post here years ago, often critically. There were a group of others who posted too that I enjoyed some joshing with. Somewhere I got out of the habit.
My politics were/are different from yours in some areas, the same in others, and in some cases I just don’t know the answers.
But when I posted here, too often I focused on the disagreements. I also focused on things that were… of lower importance.
But for the record, I’m a bit to the right of you on economics but I think we are both within the centrist, non-corbyn, non-Rees-mogg end of the spectrum.
On Brexit, I’m pro and always have been. But I don’t feel that strongly about it. Sorry. I think we will be ok either way. The Mervyn King view. I am democratic. I think the referendum view should be respected. It’s the people’s verdict, even if most “learned” voices seem to disagree with it.
However I think 52-48 is too small a majority to be final. I think there should be a second referendum. Arguably even a third. Possibly on the deal as you said. Again, the result should be respected if it happens. But if we leave, and if the Remainers probe right, if it is disastrous and people feel it so, then be it 5 or 10 years later there should be another “rejoin” referendum. I think I am being fair so far?
I suppose where I get a bit cynical – is I think some remainers worry not that Brexit will be a disaster but that it won’t be. I don’t think you are one of these. But some are. Or they worry that it may be a disaster for the better off portion of the 48%, but not for enough of the 52%… not enough to change the vote.
But more than this: I think the issue of mental health, and your work in this area, is much more important than Brexit vs remain, or than one brand of centrist politics vs another. So if I am permitted to post, that is what I would like to comment on as a priority for me rather than Brexit or the like. I think it’s better more people are in sound mental health than whether they in or out of the eu, or under a Tory or labour government.
Thanks for the work you do in this field. And thanks for being another example of how someone can have this affliction, yet could never be described as “weak” and so forth. I think that helps so much.