Guest blog from a ‘proper’ psychiatrist, on how the ‘nest’ can help the mind

  • Post

  • 23 September 2016

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 0

Guest blog by Peter Tyrer, Emeritus Professor of Community Psychiatry, Imperial College, London Most people who read Alastair’s account of his brother, Donald, and his eulogy at Donald's funeral, will have been invigorated and cheered by such a positive biography of someone with schizophrenia. But I suspect that few would have come across similar stories, as the media has a general tendency to report only the bad news about severe mental illness. As someone who has been practising psychiatry for 51 years I can truly say that Donald’s story is not an isolated one. But it could become much more frequent if we adopted new ways of looking at schizophrenia and all forms of chronic mental illness. In the early 1990s I was looking after some of the most severe cases of mental illness in the country, when my catchment area included central London. There is a phenomenon commonly called ‘social drift’ which describes the tendency of people with severe mental illness to gravitate to the centre of large towns and cities, and London of course is a prime example of this. Most people I was involved in treating had been ill for years and, unfortunately, were in the ten percent minority who had made little or no response to standard treatments for schizophrenia. They were fed up with psychiatry, highly critical of what they commonly called ‘the system’ (the service that allegedly looked after them but which seemed to be primarily looking after itself) and had lost all faith in standard therapies. At this point I introduced to treatment that subsequently became known as ‘nidotherapy’ (nest therapy). This is named after the nest, an excellent natural example of an environment that will adjust to any shape that is placed within it. So instead of trying more and more treatments that never seemed to work, the focus was changed to altering all aspects of the environment – physical, social and personal – so as to make a better fit between person and setting. One essential part of this was the need for the patient to be the driving force. There is a tendency for paternalism to take over when deciding on environmental changes for patients – ‘we are the experts and we know what is best for you’ - but this is abhorred in nidotherapy. A large part of treatment is involved in getting to know the patient really well and to find out what changes in the environment are really wanted. These have to be realistic and be subjected to a reasonable timetable so that they can be monitored. This approach has been remarkably successful with some patients and supports increasing awareness that patient choice is an important factor in outcome. Of course Donald did not receive nidotherapy in the formal sense. But the University of Glasgow practised it perfectly when they made him the official piper for the University. They knew he had schizophrenia, but they also knew he was an excellent piper, and so his illness was discounted. It is quite clear that this role was also what Donald wanted, and the fact that he was carrying out an important task on behalf of the University, not a token one that is so common in those with severe mental illness, meant that his self esteem was maintained and that in many ways he considered himself to be much more important than his brother. We need more organisations like the University of Glasgow to be far-seeing and generous in their understanding of mental illness. We are trying to promote this by developing nidotherapy across the world, not just in the United Kingdom. To date, Sweden has been the most generous in embracing it. The Donald saga, for it is indeed a saga of considerable proportion, is an excellent example of the advantages of nidotherapy in practice, and should be a beacon for those who want to move the treatment of severe mental illness forward. If you want to read more about nidotherapy go to www.nidotherapy.com , and, even better, registerto attend one of our nidotherapy workshops at Newark every February. You can also support nidotherapy by coming to ‘The Death of King John’ at the Palace Theatre in Newark on 19th October, the 800th anniversary of King John’s death in Newark Castle in 1216. If anyone needed nidotherapy, it was King John, but he was 800 years out of time. PS from Alastair … I have had some inquiries about where people can buy copies of Donald's bagpipe CDs. Glasgow University kindly donated all unsold stock to the family and we have donated several hundred of his CDs to the Scottish Association for Mental Health. The charity will be using them to raise funds. We will also be donating his several sets of bagpipes to young pipers who cannot afford their own.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

210. Andy Burnham: My Relationship With Starmer, Brexit Lies and Emotion in Politics

How will he change Britain’s relationship with the EU? Why has he agreed to publish details of meetings following the Manchester City scandal? With the Trump administration planning to livestream a ... Continue

12 October 2026

Alastair Campbell and Mishal Husain with the book Persevilience, The New World

Oct

22

2026

Alastair Campbell and Mishal Husain live at Cadogan Hall

He’s invented a word. He says it’s the word the world needs now. She’s going to make him explain why. Alastair joins acclaimed broadcaster Mishal Husain on stage to discuss his new book, Per... Continue

578. Alastair and Michael Gove Disagree Agreeably on Brexit and Israel

Will there be another EU referendum, despite Andy Burnham promising not to re-run old Brexit arguments? Will Michael Gove ever criticise Israel's actions in Palestine, and if not, why not? What do the... Continue

8 October 2026

577. Is Badenoch Finally Stopping Farage and Why Are French Schools on Fire?

With Reform bogged down in scandal, and Kemi Badenoch setting out her political vision at Conservative Party conference, have the Tories finally wrestled momentum on the right of British politics away... Continue

7 October 2026

501 cover for web

Alastair Campbell’s diary: The door that leads back to the EU is finally open. Now let’s walk through it

How fitting that new talk of joining again coincided with the 500th issue of The New World, originally founded to oppose Brexit... Continue

6 October 2026

209. Shabana Mahmood: Palestine Action, Faith and What I Told Starmer

Is the government's ban on Palestine Action lawful, or overreaching? Why can't Britain just send small boats straight back to France? Can faith and public duty coexist in modern British politics? Ro... Continue

5 October 2026

576. How Xi is Outplaying Trump and Tensions in Northern Ireland

As Trump becomes the first American president to personally welcome a visiting head of state off a plane since JFK greeted Harold Macmillan in 1962, did his summit with President Xi signal improving U... Continue

1 October 2026

575. Alastair Reacts to Burnham’s Speech and Rory’s Viral Stare

Will scrapping the triple lock be electorally perilous for Burnham, or can his vision of a national care service convince the public and his party that it’s time for pension reform? Did being Mayor ... Continue

29 September 2026