Thanks to Charlie Falconer and Dominic Grieve – yes, I know he is a Tory

  • Post

  • 21 October 2009

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 6

This could be a first - a blog containing thanks to a Tory. Not just any old Tory, but the shadow justice secretary Dominic Grieve. Mr Grieve debated the future of human rights with former Lord Chancellor Charlie Falconer in front of a room full of human rights lawyers at Doughty Street chambers in London last night. The event was the idea of what the papers might call my common-law-brother-in-law, Gavin Millar QC, in support of Leukaemia Research's efforts to raise 50k in memory of Henry Hodge as part of our 50th anniversary celebrations next year, when we want 50 such 50k donations, and 'in memory of Henry Hodge'  to be one of the first. We are still counting, and still chasing a few cheques, but the proceeds from last night are well into five figures already, so many thanks to Dominic, Charlie, Gavin, to Polly Toynbee who chaired it, and to all those who paid to hear the debate. There - I've said it. Thanks to Dominic. That is me thanking a Tory. Enjoy the moment. It was great to see Charlie back in action. I always enjoyed working with him, and he was a good brain to have around when difficult questions were being addressed. Last night, with his usual wit and his usual shirt-hanging-out-of-trousers look, he tried to pick up inconsistencies between Mr Grieve's speech to his party conference -  shall we say sceptical on human rights - and the pro human rights speech he made last night to a room full of human rights lawyers. Perhaps the funniest moment of the evening came when Charlie said that if the Toies got into power, Dominic was 'our best hope for human rights ... because you should see the rest.' But as I am being in kindly and grateful mood, I will merely take at face value Mr Grieve's commitment that a Tory government would operate within the ECHR, his expressions of support for the Human Rights Act, albeit with some criticisms too, and his belief that any changes would be to extend rather than curtail rights. So thanks again to all of them. If you'd have said to me in the morning that I would enjoy an evening listening to lawyers arguing about human rights, I would have been a bit dubious, what with Champions League being on the telly last night. But I did. So did Henry's widow Margaret. So will the Leikaemia Research bank manager. And no, not so that he can use it to jack up his bonus.

6 responses to “Thanks to Charlie Falconer and Dominic Grieve – yes, I know he is a Tory”

  1. A rare bit of heartening news. Uplifting too.
    And it gets better as you can now watch Chelsea live on ITV tonight.

  2. Tories in charge of human rights? Come off it. Next they’ll be putting your friend Paul Dacre in charge of the Press Complaints Commission code! Oh, they did …

  3. The HRA is a superb piece of legislation, one of the best things the Labour government has done. I sometimes think that you emphasised the wrong reasons for doing it, but the end product is what matters and I for one celebrate its presence on the Statute Book. Most of the criticisms of it are based on myth.

  4. ‘The HRA is a superb piece of legislation’

    That has to be the funniest statement I’ve ever read on here. The idea in principle is great, the legislation itself and the way it has been applied has been a disaster.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

206. How Putin’s War Changed Finland Forever (Sanna Marin)

Following Putin's war in Ukraine, how politically challenging was it committing Finland to join NATO? What was it like becoming the world's youngest sitting prime minister at 34? Why did a scandal ove... Continue

14 September 2026

“Our Generation Was Lied To”: Two Gen Z MPs on Fixing Politics

To hear the full series “The Gen Z Story”, sign up at the restispolitics.com – use your student email for a discount How do you get older colleagues to take you seriously when you become an MP ... Continue

11 September 2026

570. Why Trump Acts Like a Russian Asset and Miliband’s West Bank Sanctions

After Trump’s latest betrayal of Ukraine, why does he act like a Russian asset? Has John Healy already missed his moment to be a radical Chancellor, and does Ed Miliband’s move to impose economic ... Continue

10 September 2026

569. Farage’s Foreign Funding Scandal and Germany’s Far-Right Breakthrough

As the Alternative for Germany party secured its best ever election result in Saxony-Anhalt, is the country about to get its first far-right state premier since the Nazi Party, and will Chancellor Fri... Continue

9 September 2026

497 campbell books

Alastair Campbell’s diary: Books are the key to understanding the world. That’s why Putin wants to burn them

Putin wants an all-out attack on Ukraine's culture - and on the things that make life bearable in horrific times... Continue

9 September 2026

205. Anthony Scaramucci: Why America Keeps Making the Same Mistakes

Why does Anthony Scaramucci think Osama bin Laden is “winning”, and what has the War on Terror really cost America? From letting China into the WTO to bailing out the banks in 2008, how did Americ... Continue

7 September 2026

Becoming Burnham: The Manchester Arena Call, Westminster Plotting, and Keir vs Andy

To hear the full episode, and the whole series, sign up at therestispolitics.com How did Andy Burnham learn about the Manchester Arena bombing? Would he still have tried to become PM had Keir Starmer... Continue

3 September 2026

568. MAGA’s Plan to Make Britain Look Broken and Iceland’s ‘Brexit’ Moment

Did Iceland's rejection of EU membership talks repeat the same mistakes as Britain's Remain campaign, and does it hand a dangerous propaganda win to Farage, Putin, and the wider anti-European right? A... Continue

3 September 2026