Should Phil Woolas call Clegg in his defence?

  • Post

  • 11 November 2010

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 13

The best bits of Private Eye often come from the spoof press reports, which mock both the people they are about, and often the media and the manner of its reporting. There is one such funny piece this week under the headline 'Woolas fury at re-run in Oldham.' The story, from 'Rotters' agency, goes as follows: 'Mr Phil Woolas, Labour MP for Oldham East, last night slammed a High Court order which forced him to stand again for his constituency, after making 'false allegations about his opponents in the general election.' He said: 'When I mislead the voters about Lib Dem policies, I get the book thrown at me ... when Nick Clegg does it, he gets to be deputy prime minister.' Ho ho, I chuckled. But then chuckle turned to the thought that why yes, very good point Mr Spoofman from Rotters. I hope Mr Woolas reads Private Eye. I hope the point gets made more widely. Who knows, if Clegg, Cable, Huhne, Alexander and Co expose any more of their election pledges as anything but, perhaps a few judges could get together and order a re-run of the whole general election?

13 responses to “Should Phil Woolas call Clegg in his defence?”

  1. What Woolas did was wrong but the ‘Rotters’ point made was one I made as soon as the case was brought.

    Anyone who gets a Lib Dem Focus will no what is said in them by the Lib Dems.

    When does a lie become a lie which is sufficient enough to end up in a court case? At the moment it would appear when its a Labour seat and the ConDems are doing the protesting.

  2. Fair point. Personally I am glad that Harriet Harman and co have distanced themselves from Woolas. He always came across as very slimy. Labour is better off without him.

  3. What is your take on Woolas though?

    It wasn’t that he lied about what he stood for (as with the lib send) but lied about an opponent.

    I’ve never experienced such election material, probably cos I’ve only lived in “safe” seats, but I would have been appaled by a leaflet like that coming into my letterbox. I would have reported it.

  4. Clegg may yet be hoist by his own petard. If you remember what he pretentiously described as “the biggest shake-up in our democracy since the Reform Act of 1832″, he promised a ‘Right of Recall’ of MPs who had “done wrong” where 10,000 constituents signed a petition demanding an election.

    Taking Clegg’s advice, NUS President Aaron Porter is now campaigning to get 10,000 signatures in Liberal Democrat constituencies (many of which are university towns) calling for a recall vote due to the way they were misled over the LibDems’ supposed stance on tuition fees.

    Hat-tip to Bob Piper. http://www.bobpiper.co.uk/2010/11/get-signing/

  5. A re-run of the general election! That’s the best idea I’ve heard since May. I would be willing to bet the outcome would be very different now. Come back Gordon Brown. All is forgiven including selling off all/some of the nations’ gold reserves.
    I don’t actually know what was written in P. Woolas’ election leaflets, but I assume it must have been signed off by senior Labour people? Or, maybe not. I shall endeavor to find out unless someone is good enough to enlighten me.

  6. Seriously

    Jim Devine et al will be calling David Cameron and others who benefited from the lax MPs’ expenses system……

    I would…

  7. The trouble is that the law says you can’t tell lies about your opponent. it doesn’t say you can’t tell lies about yourself. And anyway, Nick Clegg now says he regrets saying it. So that’s all right then.
    Though having stood as a Labour candidate in both council and parliamentary elections, I’m amazed that it should be the Liberals of all people who complain about lying.

  8. With your alledged support for the Moribund/Harperson axis, you must give us a clue as to your stance on Woolas’s expulsion.

  9. Off topic – but on topic for Armistice day.

    I was much moved to see the PM laying a wreath at the Imjin River, the site of our bloodiest battle in the Korean war – 93 dead either in the battle or in captivity after.

    Tucked away in Gloucester cathedral (where I observed the two minute silence) is an inconspicuous and unadorned memorial to the Gloucestershires held as POW’s after the Imjin battle until September 1953:

    A small stone cross made by one of those held captive.

    Easily passed by. Easily ignored. Easily forgotten.

    Not today.

  10. The way the Labour leadership treated Phil Woolas is disgraceful. Can I ask them to be as nasty on this condem governemnt as they were on Phil Woolas?

  11. Alastair:

    Off-Topic…..You seem to be all over the place in excerpts and interviews for George Bush’s “Decision Points”. Are you going to give us your perspective?

  12. I AGREE PHIL WOOLAS SHOULD CALL ON CLEGG, CABLE,HUHNE, AND ALEXANDER AND ALL THE LIB DEMS BECAUSE THEY ARE THE BIGGEST LIARS IN BRITAIN AFTER SIGNING A PLEDGE TO NOT RAISE TUITION FEES THEN TREBLEING FEES .THE JUDGES IF THEY WERE BEING FAIR WOULD MAKE ALLTHE LIB DEMS STAND DOWN AND STAND FOR ELECTION BECAUSE THEY WOULD NOT HAVE HAD THE SEATS IN PARLIAMENT TO SUPPORT ANY PARTY IF THEY HAD TOLD THE TRUTH THE PEOPLE WOULD NOT HAVE VOTED FOR THEM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

589. The Trump-Xi-Putin Summit and Can the UK Ever Trust America Again?

With Trump, Xi and Putin set to meet this week, what is it really like sitting across the negotiating table from world leaders, and what makes dealing with China so different? With the Jensen Huang an... Continue

17 November 2026

215. Is Burnham Doing Enough to Learn From Starmer’s Mistakes? | Mariana Mazzucato

Why has Britain under-invested for decades, and can “mission-led” government fix it? Is the UK government being "infantilised" by consultants? Why is the US outgrowing Europe, and what should Andy... Continue

16 November 2026

What Living Under ISIS Taught Me About Extremism

Twenty-five years after 9/11, does terrorism still pose an existential threat to humanity? How do ordinary people become extremists — and why is it a mistake to generalise about the “type” of pe... Continue

13 November 2026

588. Is Britain Prepared for Cyber Warfare and The ‘Plot’ to Undermine the UN

As supermarket fridges are hacked and bomb threats are called in, how is AI accelerating the rate of cyberattacks, and can Britain’s defences keep up? Who is in the running to become the next UN Sec... Continue

12 November 2026

587. Will a Weakened Trump Make the World More Dangerous?

Following the disastrous midterm results for the Republicans, where will Trump turn his attention for the last two years of his presidency, and what will the MAGA movement look like without him? With ... Continue

11 November 2026

214. What Can The UK Learn From How South Africa Ended Apartheid? (Paul van Zyl)

How can politicians rebuild trust after decades of division? How do you get political enemies to sit down at the same table? What are some of Nelson Mandela's best - and funniest - moments? Alastair ... Continue

9 November 2026

586. Trump’s Midterms Disaster: What Happens Next?

Why did Trump concede defeat so quickly and pledge to work with Democrats, and what does this mean for the final two years of his presidency, including his influence on the world stage? Was this a cos... Continue

4 November 2026