Cameron, Osborne, Hunt should watch tonight’s Panorama to see the gap between their words and their country

  • Post

  • 24 October 2015

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 3

I had my run-ins with Panorama when working for Tony Blair, usually because they tended to take a grain of truth from somewhere and flam it up into something worthier of a right-wing tabloid than the BBC. But tonight's version is all the stronger for being somewhat understated, telling the story rather than shouting it or ramming it down throats. I know our government leaders are busy (almost all) men, but I hope they find time to watch it. Because while they talk the talk on mental health, as the Prime Minister did in his party conference speech, the documentary shows the reality of mental health services on the frontline. What is clear, as so many working in mental health care already know, is that demand for services is growing, partly I hope through greater awareness and the lessening of taboos, but more because of austerity, social security and other service cuts; but at the same time as demand is growing, the supply of services needed is being cut. When I protested that a mental health emergency facility in Camden was being closed down, I was told that the reason was that 'it never runs at full capacity.' That is surely the point, that those who are in a facility get the care they need, but there is at least some capacity for emergency admissions, given that is the purpose of such a place. The consequence of that twisted logic is clear in Panorama's portrayal of Barnet, Enfield and Haringey mental health trust, which documents the very real human consequences of the phrase 'pressure on beds.' We see staff constantly on telephone conference calls trying to find beds for patients often being brought to their attention by police under the Mental Health Act. With the system operating at 'over 100 per cent capacity,' for each new patient that must get a bed, the clinicians and administrators have to make a decision about who should go out. They must nominate 'the least unwell patient,' regardless of how unwell that patient may be. Imagine if this were to happen in a cancer ward, that the 'least cancerous patient' had to make way for a new diagnosis. It is because it is mental health, which has gone back to being a cinderella service under this government, that this is allowed to happen, and that barely a peep is heard. Cuts to mental health services have been 20percent higher than cuts to other health services. The trust being examined by Panorama has lost a third of beds in five years, and this has happened at the same time as a surge of sectionings under the Mental Health Act of people thought to be a danger to themselves, others or society. Cameron and Osborne could probably do with a quiet night in front of the telly after their busy week being nice to the Chinese. They should spend it watching Panorama, and witness the massive gap between the caring rhetoric of understanding, and the calamitous reality of their policies, and the impact on some of our sickest fellow citizens.
  • Panorama on BBC1 8.30pm Monday, Britain's Mental Health Crisis

3 responses to “Cameron, Osborne, Hunt should watch tonight’s Panorama to see the gap between their words and their country”

  1. Everything will start to fall to pieces in 2016, from April. Some say Osborne will do a most humongous U-turn in his Autumn budget statement, but will he? Will his ego allow him? This fantasy that they are peddling that families will be better off is just that. The time lag between this great plan, higher minimum wage, and hoping landlords drop rents, all nonsense. It is not so much that families will struggle with their financials, which they will terribly, but what about the knock on effects to the economies in various regions? It’s all a revolving circle, cuts mean more borrowing, as we have found since 2010. National economic activity will spiral down, since who wants to chance it setting up a business, hairdressers or a shop or something, or upwards more adventurous? Napoleon might have said we are a nation of shopkeepers, but it seem we will be a nation of poundshop keepers, and loan sharks with 4500% APR levels. We are going to the dogs. Will make the 1980s for regions and London look a tea party.

  2. What constitutes a threat to society to warrant being sectioned. Is that even legal? Sounds authoritarian. And Labour didn’t legislate for therapeutic environments when it changed the Mental Health Act, sadly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

482. A Trumpian Year, the Politics of Hope and Highlights of 2025

What surprised Rory and Alastair most about 2025? Why does Trump's presidency feel even more chaotic than expected? And who gets their vote for campaigner of the year? Join Rory and Alastair... Continue

25 December 2025

481. Polanski, Macron & al-Sharaa: The Best & Worst Politicians of 2025

Who deserves the title of UK politician of the year - and who gets worst? What was the most consequential moment of Trump's presidency so far? And can Rory convince Alastair that Christmas is... Continue

24 December 2025

167. Faith, Depression, and Finding Calm in the Chaos (Professor Mark Williams)

From Parliament to Prison, how can people find calm in chaotic environments? How does one cope with grief during the festive period? What are some successful ways to combat depression? Rory... Continue

22 December 2025

Will AI Take Our Jobs? (Ep 2)

Is AI a genuine productivity revolution, or just another tech bubble? Are any jobs safe from the advent of AI? And, can the UK harness the innovation, or will it fall behind? Rory Stewart is... Continue

19 December 2025

480. Trump, China, and the Scramble for Latin America (Question Time)

What’s really driving Trump’s interventions in Venezuela and the rest of Latin America – oil, drugs, or democracy? Is Labour failing on its promise to reform and ultimately abolish the ... Continue

18 December 2025

479. Russian Influence in Britain: How Exposed Are We?

Why are Britain’s top military and intelligence chiefs sounding the alarm about Putin’s influence and future plans? How deeply has Russia already penetrated British politics, media, and p... Continue

17 December 2025

Alastair Campbell’s diary: American civilisation is at risk – but I’m still going

If they check my social media posts at the border, I might well be on the first plane back, which tells you Trump’s talk about free speech is nothing but a sham... Continue

17 December 2025

Article

Posted by

166. John Swinney: An Independent Scotland Is An Open Scotland

What is the future of the Scottish independence movement? How does the SNP rebuild trust and support for independence after a series of bruising scandals? Why did the Scottish First Minister ... Continue

15 December 2025